by: Joe Sasson
Reading Time: 3 minutes
This one’s for DTC founders, supply chain nerds, and anyone obsessed with turning commodity products (yes, even pots and pans) into cult brands.
Caraway started in 2019 after founder Jordan Nathan burned his Teflon pan – literally. Fast-forward to 2024: $800M revenue, 500% YoY growth, and 15+ retail partners.
Why Caraway?
- They cracked omnichannel profitability while balancing Shopify, Amazon, and retail
- Turned cookware (a 4,000-year-old product category) into a lifestyle brand
- Proved sustainability sells – 85% of customers cite eco-friendliness as key purchase driver
Today, I’ll break down:
- The Shopify-to-Amazon flywheel driving 280% order growth
- Their product differentiation playbook (with exact creative formulas)
- Community-building tactics that boosted LTV by 4.1x
Let’s get cookin’!
OMNICHANNEL STRATEGY
The Shopify-Amazon-Retail Trifecta
While DTC brands fight over direct sales vs. Amazon, Caraway does both – profitably.
Shopify: The Brand Hub
- Design-first storytelling: Interactive product pages emphasize ceramic coatings and recyclable packaging (Site Link)
- No discounts: Maintains $395 average order value (AOV) for cookware sets
- First-party data: 70% of email signups come from Shopify-exclusive content (e.g., “Guide to Non-Toxic Cooking”)
Amazon: The Scale Engine
- Prime-optimized bundles: “Kitchen Starter Set” drives 30% of Amazon sales ($240M/year)
- Branded packaging: Negotiated with Amazon to keep unboxing experience intact (rare for DTC)
- Review strategy: 15K+ 5-star reviews generated via post-purchase emails offering free recipe eBooks
Retail: The Credibility Play
- Partnered with Target, Crate & Barrel, and Sur La Table for in-store placements
- 40% of revenue ($320M) comes from wholesale, balancing DTC margins
Key Metric: 99.9% on-time shipping rate via ITS Logistics’ multi-node network.
PRODUCT INNOVATION
How to Make Pots & Pans Viral
Caraway’s product strategy combines safety, aesthetics, and behavioral psychology:
1. Pain Point Obsession
- Teflon-free positioning: Built entire brand narrative around founder’s poisoning story
- Stackable design: Solved cabinet clutter issues (the #1 cookware complaint per Exploding Topics)
2. Color Psychology
Launched with muted “wedding registry” hues (Sage, Cream), then expanded to bold Gen Z-friendly colors (Marigold, Perracotta):
- 65% of customers under 35 bought limited-edition colors
- Instagram Reels comparing color options drove 25% of site traffic
3. Scarcity Engine
- Drops new collections quarterly (e.g., 2023 Pro Series generated $50M in pre-orders)
- Amazon-exclusive bundles sell out within 72 hours
Your Takeaway: Caraway doesn’t sell cookware – they sell confidence in the kitchen. Mirror this by anchoring product development to emotional outcomes, not features.
COMMUNITY & RETENTION
The 4.1x LTV/CAC Playbook
Caraway’s retention strategy blends education, exclusivity, and UGC:
Post-Purchase Drip Campaign
- Day 1: “Your Ceramic Care Guide” (PDF download)
- Day 7: “Join the Caraway Cooks Club” (FB group pitch)
- Day 14: “Recipe eBook + 10% Off Next Purchase”
Referral Program
- “Give $25, Get $25” model drives 15% of new customers
- Top referrers get early access to product launches
UGC Strategy
- Repurposes customer kitchen photos into Meta ads (ROAS 4.2x)
- TikTok hashtag #CarawayKitchen has 80M+ views
Key Metric: 50% of revenue comes from repeat purchases.
WRAP-UP
Caraway’s playbook offers three universal lessons:
- Omnichannel ≠ Compromise: Use Shopify for branding, Amazon for scale, retail for credibility
- Product Story > Product Specs: Anchor innovation to emotional outcomes (safety, confidence)
- Community = Retention: Turn customers into collaborators via UGC and exclusive access
Share this with a founder who needs it →
Resources: